A Google news search for the phrase climate change today revealed a story on Climate Home News claiming climate change is harming Indian sugarcane production. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Amidst normal year-to-year boom and bust, which tracks India’s historically variable monsoon cycles, India’s sugarcane production and yields have increased dramatically as the Earth has warmed modestly and carbon dioxide concentrations have increased. [emphasis, links added]
As with other crops, the evidence clearly suggests climate change is benefitting India’s sugarcane producers.
In the Climate Home News story, titled “India’s sugarcane farmers struggle to cope with droughts and floods,” the authors note that sugarcane accounts for 10 percent of India’s agricultural production, with India being both the world’s biggest producer and consumer of sugarcane.
Having established the critical nature of sugarcane production to India’s agricultural sector, unfortunately, the writers then leap into unsubstantiated climate alarmism, making claims about changing weather conditions causing a decline in sugar production.
“The rainfall during the monsoon season, between June and September, was erratic this year,” [Kalua Mehmood, a sugarcane farmer in western Uttar Pradesh] told Climate Home News. “Mehmood is one of millions of Indian sugarcane farmers who is suffering the onslaught of climate change.”
Indian agriculture is dependent on the monsoon season. There is no data showing that as the Earth has warmed, monsoons have become more intense or infrequent.
If monsoons aren’t becoming erratic, novel fluctuations in rainfall and drought patterns can’t be harming Indian sugarcane farmers.
Indeed, data from the U.N. Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) show that sugar production and yields in India have grown substantially since 1990, with the increase in yields being attributable in part to the fertilization effect of rising carbon dioxide concentrations.
FAO data show that between 1990 and 2020:
- Indian sugarcane production increased by more than 64 percent, setting new records for production 10 times during the 30-year period;
- Indian sugarcane yields grew by nearly 18 percent, setting new records five times. (See the graphic below)
As with farming everywhere, production is closely tied to the weather; it may be true that some Indian sugarcane producers suffered a down year in 2022 due to this year’s variable rainfall.
However, there is no long-term trend in weather variability or any evidence suggesting monsoon-dependent sugarcane production is being threatened by long-term climate change. One or two down years do not a climate crisis make, Climate Home News.
Check the data before you go to press stoking indefensible climate alarm.
Top image by Bishnu Sarangi via Pixabay
Read more at Climate Realism
The only real climate changes have occurred over the last 800ky when the earth went from full blown glaciation to interglaciation.
The list is growing. False claims of climate change adversely impacting production of grapes, chocolate, rice, and many other crops. The climate change movement is desperate to find excuses to implement their radical agenda.
Back in the 1970’s it was Global Cooling and a New Ice age was coming the very same liberal rags like Time and Newsweek was giving it top coverage in their weekly rags