• Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Climate Change Dispatch
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Who We Are
  • Facts Vs. Fearmongering
    • Real science vs Junk Science
      • 1100-plus Peer-Reviewed Studies
      • 97% – Myth of the Climate Change Consensus
      • Michael Crichton: Aliens Cause Global Warming
      • Climate change and its causes
      • Climate Science Primer
      • CO2 is not pollution
      • Deceptive Surface Temperature Records
      • Editorial: Great Global Warming Hoax
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 1
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 2
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 3
      • Why CO2 Is A Minor Player In Global Climate
      • Why Politicized Science Is So Dangerous
    • Facts Not Fear
      • A Simple Question For Climate Alarmists
      • Climate Change – The Facts
      • Climate Change Fears Are Empirically Baseless
      • Global Warming 101
      • Global Warming Q&A
      • Understanding The Medieval Warm Period
      • Ocean Cycles and Climate
      • Overview of Plate Climatology Theory
      • Precautionary Principle
      • Should We Celebrate Carbon Dioxide?
      • The Skeptics Handbook
      • Weather Versus Climate
      • Why I’m a GW skeptic
      • Winning the climate debate with facts
      • Why Aliens Cause Global Warming
    • Greenhouse FAQs
      • CO2, Plants, & Industry
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • Is global warming real?
      • Measuring temperature
      • Swimming in CO2?
      • Scientists urge caution?
      • Today’s warming trend
      • Variations in temperature
    • Gore’s Greatest Goofs
      • Deconstructing the Truth
      • Fact-Checking Al Gore’s Latest Predictions
      • How Gore Created The Global Warming Hoax
    • Inside Real Climate
      • Closer look at the 97% Consensus
      • GW’s Amazing Story
      • IPCC gets failing grade
      • Real Climate Exposed!
      • Truth about Real Climate
      • We’ve Been Conned
      • What is there a 97% consensus about?
    • Behind the IPCC
      • 1,000 Scientists Dissent
      • Climategate: Caught Green-Handed!
      • Climategate Inquiries
      • Climategate Inquiries 2
      • NIPCC Report Now Available
      • Understanding the Climategate Inquiries
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Who We Are
  • Facts Vs. Fearmongering
    • Real science vs Junk Science
      • 1100-plus Peer-Reviewed Studies
      • 97% – Myth of the Climate Change Consensus
      • Michael Crichton: Aliens Cause Global Warming
      • Climate change and its causes
      • Climate Science Primer
      • CO2 is not pollution
      • Deceptive Surface Temperature Records
      • Editorial: Great Global Warming Hoax
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 1
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 2
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 3
      • Why CO2 Is A Minor Player In Global Climate
      • Why Politicized Science Is So Dangerous
    • Facts Not Fear
      • A Simple Question For Climate Alarmists
      • Climate Change – The Facts
      • Climate Change Fears Are Empirically Baseless
      • Global Warming 101
      • Global Warming Q&A
      • Understanding The Medieval Warm Period
      • Ocean Cycles and Climate
      • Overview of Plate Climatology Theory
      • Precautionary Principle
      • Should We Celebrate Carbon Dioxide?
      • The Skeptics Handbook
      • Weather Versus Climate
      • Why I’m a GW skeptic
      • Winning the climate debate with facts
      • Why Aliens Cause Global Warming
    • Greenhouse FAQs
      • CO2, Plants, & Industry
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • Is global warming real?
      • Measuring temperature
      • Swimming in CO2?
      • Scientists urge caution?
      • Today’s warming trend
      • Variations in temperature
    • Gore’s Greatest Goofs
      • Deconstructing the Truth
      • Fact-Checking Al Gore’s Latest Predictions
      • How Gore Created The Global Warming Hoax
    • Inside Real Climate
      • Closer look at the 97% Consensus
      • GW’s Amazing Story
      • IPCC gets failing grade
      • Real Climate Exposed!
      • Truth about Real Climate
      • We’ve Been Conned
      • What is there a 97% consensus about?
    • Behind the IPCC
      • 1,000 Scientists Dissent
      • Climategate: Caught Green-Handed!
      • Climategate Inquiries
      • Climategate Inquiries 2
      • NIPCC Report Now Available
      • Understanding the Climategate Inquiries
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Climate Change Dispatch
No Result
View All Result

States Pursuing Climate Lawsuits Rated ‘Judicial Hellholes’ By Major Legal Group

by SPENCER WALRATH
December 17, 2018, 1:40 PM
in News and Opinion
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
4

exxon climate protest justiceThe trial lawyers bringing climate liability lawsuits against energy producers in California and New York City may have contributed to those locations topping the list of “judicial hellholes,” according to the American Tort Reform Foundation’s (ATRF) 2018-2019 Judicial Hellhole report.

ATRF’s annual report identifies the states, cities, and courts with the most “unfair and unbalanced” laws and procedures in the country.

California and New York City were crowned the worst and third worst, respectively, while Florida earned the number two spot, coming amid media reports of Sher Edling LLP and EarthRights International pitching their climate lawsuits to several South Florida communities.

New York Attorney General Uses Power for Political Gain

In addition to a litigation environment described as “brazenly plaintiff-favoring” where defendants are “entering the batter’s box with two strikes already called,” the ATRF cites the New York Attorney General’s climate lawsuit against ExxonMobil as a particularly salient reason for the city’s Judicial Hellhole ranking.

Under Eric Schneiderman’s tenure, the Office of the Attorney General became increasingly politicized. Using the Martin Act – a unique New York law from 1921 which grants the Attorney General extensive powers to investigate suspected financial fraud – Schneiderman began investigating ExxonMobil, claiming that the company misled investors about climate change.

After Schneiderman’s sudden resignation due to allegations of physical abuse, Barbara Underwood sustained her predecessor’s flawed investigation into ExxonMobil, suing the company in October over purported inconsistencies in disclosures to investors about the effects of still-hypothetical climate change regulations on its business.

However, as EID has previously reported, it was clear from the beginning that New York’s investigation of ExxonMobil was politically motivated, designed to garner headlines rather than uncover any actual legal violations.

The actions of Eric Schneiderman and Barbara Underwood – expanding and enhancing the powers of the Office of the Attorney General for political gain – represent a concerning trend in New York’s legal system, according to the ATRF.

California’s ‘Abusive’ Legal System Hurts Citizens

The climate lawsuits in California are central to the state’s low ranking by the ATRF, which said that litigation burdens not only California courts but also consumers in the state.

In 2018, the cost of living in California jumped from the third- to second-highest in the United States, due in large part to lawsuit abuse and excessive state regulations driving up housing, food, and energy prices.

In fact, a Perryman Group study released in September quantified the estimated impact of excessive tort on California’s economy, finding it costs $11.6 billion in annual direct costs and 197,776 lost jobs.

Despite their Hellhole status, judges in California and New York have bucked the trend and dismissed some of the climate lawsuits brought against major oil companies.

In both of their respective motions to dismiss, U.S. District Judge William Alsup and U.S. District Judge John Keenan noted that the judiciary is not the appropriate venue to address a global, political issue such as climate change.

The ATRF report echoes this sentiment:

“One topic that should not be in dispute, however, is the role of litigation in this area. Courts are appropriate for settling legal disputes, not setting environmental policy that has a profound impact on countless aspects of our daily lives and the continuing prospects for a strong and vibrant economy”

Florida’s Race to the Bottom

Florida was ranked the second-worst hellhole in ATRF’s report this year, but a new batch of climate lawsuits may give California a run for worst overall.

The Washington Free Beacon recently reported on Sher Edling’s efforts to pitch Miami and Miami Beach on filing climate liability lawsuits on a contingency fee basis, meaning the trial lawyers stand to make hundreds of millions of dollars should they win.

EarthRights International, which is representing Boulder, Colo., in its climate lawsuit, has also approached Ft. Lauderdale and other municipalities in Florida about getting involved.

Despite these aggressive efforts, which include a PR campaign that has expanded to include billboards, a “news” site, and a podcast, Florida officials have refused to join the fray.

There is no shortage of climate litigation critics in the state, including the former attorney general and U.S. Congressman Bill McCollum, who said the lawsuits are “not a constructive way to address the issue.”

These lawsuits are just another example of out-of-state trial lawyers looking for an easy target by, say, targeting a “judicial hellhole.” McCollum continued:

“Large, national trial firms looking to make a big contingency fee killing are the driving force behind the recent proliferation of public nuisance lawsuits being filed by localities…They’re looking for the next tobacco case and are not content just to deal with state attorneys general as in the past or rely on traditional class actions.”

Climate Litigation Part of Broader Anti-Energy Campaign

The ATRF report confirms what EID has previously reported – that the recent boom in climate litigation is part of a larger campaign to attack energy companies.

In respect to California and New York City, the coordinated network of trial attorneys, activists, and deep-pocketed donors driving the broader climate litigation campaign have found a safe harbor and set up shop in California and New York City.

Ultimately, if these lawsuits are successful, it would have a significant and far-reaching economic impact.

By manipulating the court system to act as a quasi-regulator, the climate lawsuit movement would be leaving taxpayers to shoulder the inevitably enormous financial burden.

Looking down the road, ATRF offers a stark warning of the consequences of this campaign (bold added):

This type of litigation has a profound and significant negative economic impact and should be called out for the sham that it is.

State attorneys general must remain focused on protecting the interest of the public and serving their communities, and rebuff the advances of opportunistic plaintiffs’ attorneys.

If allowed to continue unchecked, the costs will not be restricted to the companies so arbitrarily pursued.

Rather, taxpayers will foot the bill and the trial bar will move on to another scapegoat to line its pockets.

Read more at EID Climate

  • Truth
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Gettr
  • Threads
  • gab-logo Gab
  • Mastodon
  • Buffer
  • Telegram
  • Email
  • Copy Link
  • Share Using More Networks…

Popular Posts

Electric Vehicles (EVs)

The ‘Green’ Scam Of The Century: How ‘Renewables’ Increase Fossil Fuel Demands

Oct 23, 2024
News and Opinion

Antarctica Is Colder, Icier Today Than At Any Time In 5,000 Years

Apr 15, 2024
Energy

30-Plus Signs That The Climate Scam Is Collapsing

Apr 09, 2025

Comments 4

  1. Sonnyhill says:
    7 years ago

    Jaypee, all those awards and accolades are aimed at those susceptible to the willing suspension of disbelief. Keep dreaming, people, y’all made this possible. Fiction is so much more malleable than facts. Facts are problematic, stoic, awkward.
    Obama successfully sold ” hope and change “. He got the Nobel Salesman of the Year award.
    Al Gore won the same award.
    The Nobel prizes are no longer ‘dynamite’. Duds.

    Reply
  2. JayPee says:
    7 years ago

    We should be welcoming these jerks to the courts
    provided that
    the judges are capable of
    understanding logic, even common sense.

    There is NO credible proof whatsoever of a

    GREENHOUSE EFFECT

    And much less of the

    GLOBAL WARMING

    presumption.

    ALL of this propagandist idiocy
    flies in the face of

    The total rejection of the Scientific Method
    and

    The Second Law of Thermodynamics !

    Cheap fakeumentarist Mikey Moore doesn’t tell you that.

    Cheap NOBEL and Academy awardist Al Ghore
    doesn’t admit that either.

    I would also mention

    HOSANNA O’BAMA THE MAGNIFICENT

    But nobody can ascertain why he received the NOBEL PRIZE !

    Reply
  3. Dave O says:
    7 years ago

    Maybe the people of California will be as progressive as those in France, and throw off the shackles and seek true freedom.

    Reply
  4. Spurwing Plover says:
    7 years ago

    Vultures migrate south however in California and New York the vultures and the Sharks are year round residents only we call them Trial Lawyers and the Dirty Democrats are their partners in crime they oppose any kind of Tort Reform like the Protection of Lawful Commerce Act which protects Gun Makers from politicly motivated lawsuits these greedy law firms need to be reigned in and the cities bringing up these lawsuits need to face a backlash from the public against their greed

    Reply

Comments are welcome! Those that add no discussion value may be removed.Cancel reply

Stay Connected On Social Media

gab-logo

Donate Today

Beating back the alarmist narrative takes time and money. Please donate today to help!

Recent Posts

  • oil rig drillAmerica’s Energy Boom Exposes The Folly Of Britain’s Net Zero Disaster
    Oct 3, 2025
    America’s energy boom and policy flexibility are widening the economic gap with Britain, where high prices and net zero goals are stalling growth. […]
  • Arctic sunsetNew Study Shows Arctic Sea Ice Decline Slowing, Driven More by Natural Variability Than Emissions
    Oct 3, 2025
    New study shows Arctic sea ice decline has slowed since 2012, driven more by natural variability than greenhouse gas emissions. […]
  • Attorney General Rob BontaNewsom Backs Off Climate Fight As AG Bonta Doubles Down On Suing Energy Firms
    Oct 3, 2025
    Two years after launching a high-profile climate lawsuit, Newsom is backing off while AG Rob Bonta doubles down on lawfare against major energy firms. […]
  • Farm irrigationMeteorologist Debunks Reuters’ Claim That Climate Change Threatens Europe’s Resources
    Oct 2, 2025
    Data show Europe’s droughts, weather, and biodiversity issues stem from mismanagement, not climate change, despite alarmist media claims. […]
  • Russ VoughtTrump Nixes $8B In ‘Green New Scam Funding’ In NYC, Blue States
    Oct 2, 2025
    Trump DOE halted billions in green energy projects citing poor economics, DEI hiring, and weak energy impact, sparking backlash in blue states. […]
  • SherrillRising Energy Costs And Dem Green Policies Top Of Mind In NJ Gubernatorial Race
    Oct 2, 2025
    New Jersey voters face rising energy costs as Democratic green policies and offshore wind expansion drive utility bills higher. […]
  • Hochul's green stringsHochul’s Election-Year ‘Inflation Refund’ Checks Can’t Cover Costs Of Her Green Agenda
    Oct 2, 2025
    Hochul’s election-year ‘inflation refund’ checks won’t offset the soaring living costs and utility hikes her green-energy agenda created. […]
  • South Asia monsoonSouth Asia Monsoons Not Becoming More Dangerous From Climate Change, Data Confirms
    Oct 1, 2025
    Claims that climate change is making South Asia’s monsoons more extreme ignore history, data, and other major causes of flooding. […]
  • wildfire carsRick Scott Wants Answers On What California Did With Federal Wildfire Funds
    Oct 1, 2025
    Sen. Rick Scott is demanding answers on how California spent federal money earmarked for preventing and fighting wildfires. […]
  • Biden test driving an all-electric Ford F-150.Ford CEO Warns U.S. EV Sales Could Halve After Federal Subsidies End
    Oct 1, 2025
    Ford warns U.S. electric vehicle sales could drop as much as 5% after the $7,500 taxpayer-funded federal subsidies expire in a month. […]

Get Instant Email Notifications

Subscribe to receive a digest of daily stories, or get emailed once they're published. Check your Junk/Spam folder for a verification email.

Submit a tip

Please enter your email, so we know you're human.

Books You May Like

very convenient warming

exposing great lie

Have a suggestion? Let us know! We swap out books based on your input. We participate in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. See here.

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

© Portions copyright Climate Change Dispatch

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Who We Are
  • Facts Vs. Fearmongering
    • Real science vs Junk Science
      • 1100-plus Peer-Reviewed Studies
      • 97% – Myth of the Climate Change Consensus
      • Michael Crichton: Aliens Cause Global Warming
      • Climate change and its causes
      • Climate Science Primer
      • CO2 is not pollution
      • Deceptive Surface Temperature Records
      • Editorial: Great Global Warming Hoax
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 1
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 2
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 3
      • Why CO2 Is A Minor Player In Global Climate
      • Why Politicized Science Is So Dangerous
    • Facts Not Fear
      • A Simple Question For Climate Alarmists
      • Climate Change – The Facts
      • Climate Change Fears Are Empirically Baseless
      • Global Warming 101
      • Global Warming Q&A
      • Understanding The Medieval Warm Period
      • Ocean Cycles and Climate
      • Overview of Plate Climatology Theory
      • Precautionary Principle
      • Should We Celebrate Carbon Dioxide?
      • The Skeptics Handbook
      • Weather Versus Climate
      • Why I’m a GW skeptic
      • Winning the climate debate with facts
      • Why Aliens Cause Global Warming
    • Greenhouse FAQs
      • CO2, Plants, & Industry
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • Is global warming real?
      • Measuring temperature
      • Swimming in CO2?
      • Scientists urge caution?
      • Today’s warming trend
      • Variations in temperature
    • Gore’s Greatest Goofs
      • Deconstructing the Truth
      • Fact-Checking Al Gore’s Latest Predictions
      • How Gore Created The Global Warming Hoax
    • Inside Real Climate
      • Closer look at the 97% Consensus
      • GW’s Amazing Story
      • IPCC gets failing grade
      • Real Climate Exposed!
      • Truth about Real Climate
      • We’ve Been Conned
      • What is there a 97% consensus about?
    • Behind the IPCC
      • 1,000 Scientists Dissent
      • Climategate: Caught Green-Handed!
      • Climategate Inquiries
      • Climategate Inquiries 2
      • NIPCC Report Now Available
      • Understanding the Climategate Inquiries
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us

© 2025 Climate Change Dispatch

Share via
  • Facebook
  • Like
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • Tumblr
  • VKontakte
  • Print
  • Email
  • Reddit
  • Buffer
  • Love This
  • Weibo
  • Pocket
  • Xing
  • Odnoklassniki
  • WhatsApp
  • Meneame
  • Blogger
  • Amazon
  • Yahoo Mail
  • Gmail
  • AOL
  • Newsvine
  • HackerNews
  • Evernote
  • MySpace
  • Mail.ru
  • Viadeo
  • Line
  • Flipboard
  • Comments
  • SMS
  • Viber
  • Telegram
  • Subscribe
  • Facebook Messenger
  • Kakao
  • LiveJournal
  • Yammer
  • Edgar
  • Fintel
  • Mix
  • Instapaper
  • Copy Link
  • Truth
  • gab-logo Gab
  • Gettr
  • Baidu
  • Mastodon
  • Threads
  • Bluesky
Share via
  • Digg
  • Tumblr
  • VKontakte
  • Print
  • Email
  • Reddit
  • Buffer
  • Love This
  • Weibo
  • Pocket
  • Xing
  • Odnoklassniki
  • WhatsApp
  • Meneame
  • Blogger
  • Amazon
  • Yahoo Mail
  • Gmail
  • AOL
  • Newsvine
  • HackerNews
  • Evernote
  • MySpace
  • Mail.ru
  • Viadeo
  • Line
  • Flipboard
  • Comments
  • SMS
  • Viber
  • Telegram
  • Subscribe
  • Facebook Messenger
  • Kakao
  • LiveJournal
  • Yammer
  • Edgar
  • Fintel
  • Mix
  • Instapaper
  • Copy Link
  • Truth
  • gab-logo Gab
  • Gettr
  • Baidu
  • Mastodon
  • Threads
  • Bluesky