• Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Climate Change Dispatch
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Who We Are
  • Facts Vs. Fearmongering
    • Real science vs Junk Science
      • 1100-plus Peer-Reviewed Studies
      • 97% – Myth of the Climate Change Consensus
      • Michael Crichton: Aliens Cause Global Warming
      • Climate change and its causes
      • Climate Science Primer
      • CO2 is not pollution
      • Deceptive Surface Temperature Records
      • Editorial: Great Global Warming Hoax
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 1
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 2
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 3
      • Why CO2 Is A Minor Player In Global Climate
      • Why Politicized Science Is So Dangerous
    • Facts Not Fear
      • A Simple Question For Climate Alarmists
      • Climate Change – The Facts
      • Climate Change Fears Are Empirically Baseless
      • Global Warming 101
      • Global Warming Q&A
      • Understanding The Medieval Warm Period
      • Ocean Cycles and Climate
      • Overview of Plate Climatology Theory
      • Precautionary Principle
      • Should We Celebrate Carbon Dioxide?
      • The Skeptics Handbook
      • Weather Versus Climate
      • Why I’m a GW skeptic
      • Winning the climate debate with facts
      • Why Aliens Cause Global Warming
    • Greenhouse FAQs
      • CO2, Plants, & Industry
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • Is global warming real?
      • Measuring temperature
      • Swimming in CO2?
      • Scientists urge caution?
      • Today’s warming trend
      • Variations in temperature
    • Gore’s Greatest Goofs
      • Deconstructing the Truth
      • Fact-Checking Al Gore’s Latest Predictions
      • How Gore Created The Global Warming Hoax
    • Inside Real Climate
      • Closer look at the 97% Consensus
      • GW’s Amazing Story
      • IPCC gets failing grade
      • Real Climate Exposed!
      • Truth about Real Climate
      • We’ve Been Conned
      • What is there a 97% consensus about?
    • Behind the IPCC
      • 1,000 Scientists Dissent
      • Climategate: Caught Green-Handed!
      • Climategate Inquiries
      • Climategate Inquiries 2
      • NIPCC Report Now Available
      • Understanding the Climategate Inquiries
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Who We Are
  • Facts Vs. Fearmongering
    • Real science vs Junk Science
      • 1100-plus Peer-Reviewed Studies
      • 97% – Myth of the Climate Change Consensus
      • Michael Crichton: Aliens Cause Global Warming
      • Climate change and its causes
      • Climate Science Primer
      • CO2 is not pollution
      • Deceptive Surface Temperature Records
      • Editorial: Great Global Warming Hoax
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 1
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 2
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 3
      • Why CO2 Is A Minor Player In Global Climate
      • Why Politicized Science Is So Dangerous
    • Facts Not Fear
      • A Simple Question For Climate Alarmists
      • Climate Change – The Facts
      • Climate Change Fears Are Empirically Baseless
      • Global Warming 101
      • Global Warming Q&A
      • Understanding The Medieval Warm Period
      • Ocean Cycles and Climate
      • Overview of Plate Climatology Theory
      • Precautionary Principle
      • Should We Celebrate Carbon Dioxide?
      • The Skeptics Handbook
      • Weather Versus Climate
      • Why I’m a GW skeptic
      • Winning the climate debate with facts
      • Why Aliens Cause Global Warming
    • Greenhouse FAQs
      • CO2, Plants, & Industry
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • Is global warming real?
      • Measuring temperature
      • Swimming in CO2?
      • Scientists urge caution?
      • Today’s warming trend
      • Variations in temperature
    • Gore’s Greatest Goofs
      • Deconstructing the Truth
      • Fact-Checking Al Gore’s Latest Predictions
      • How Gore Created The Global Warming Hoax
    • Inside Real Climate
      • Closer look at the 97% Consensus
      • GW’s Amazing Story
      • IPCC gets failing grade
      • Real Climate Exposed!
      • Truth about Real Climate
      • We’ve Been Conned
      • What is there a 97% consensus about?
    • Behind the IPCC
      • 1,000 Scientists Dissent
      • Climategate: Caught Green-Handed!
      • Climategate Inquiries
      • Climategate Inquiries 2
      • NIPCC Report Now Available
      • Understanding the Climategate Inquiries
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
Climate Change Dispatch
No Result
View All Result

Is Youth Climate Activism An Exercise in Futility?

by Gabriël Moens
March 22, 2022, 8:58 AM
in News and Opinion
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
3

queensland mine protestIn an address to the Rural Press Club in Brisbane on March 17, the Australian Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce criticized youth climate change activists, stating: “Those carrying coffins out of Ukraine churches are not focused on climate change.” [bold, links added]

In making this curious statement, Joyce suggested that high school students should be more interested in how to defend their country from war-like calamities rather than being focused on climate change and zero-emissions rhetoric.

Climate change is certainly a crucial issue, but its multi-faceted aspects, involving conflicting and mutually exclusive scientific opinions, and generating dubious economic practices, show that it may not be amenable to a calculated activist approach.

Joyce’s comments came just a few days after a unanimous decision of the full bench of the Federal Court of Australia, Minister for the Environment v Sharma.

In their decision, the judges ruled that the state does not owe a duty of care to the nation’s youth to ensure that they are not harmed by state action (or inaction) on climate change and global warming.

Chief Justice Allsop held that the requisites of a new tort are not available because the relationship between the government and the student activists lacks the relevant nearness and proximity necessary for the imposition of a duty of care.

At one level of abstraction, we all rely on an elected government to develop and implement wise policy in the interests of all Australians, in one sense, especially the children of the country who are its future.

That is not the foundation of the law of torts. It is the foundation of responsible democratic government. The court case had been initiated by eight activist high school students, who sought to test the court’s willingness to create a new tort.

Although the case presented the court with an unusual and unexpected opportunity to further expand the scope of the law of torts, the duty to look after the welfare of all Australians, especially its youth, belongs to Australia’s democratic institutions.

Following the court’s announcement of its decision, the student activists vouched to continue to hold the government accountable for its climate change policies. There were even suggestions that leave to apply to the High Court should be pursued by their legal counsel.

This case throws up a number of questions, the answers to which are difficult and challenging. Should high school students be involved in protests and even skip school for that purpose?

If skipping school is against school policy, what considerations could be adduced to conclude that their action has redeeming features?

The answer to these challenging questions could be found, at least in part, in the concept of “symbolic speech,” according to which people, including high school students, are entitled to be involved in the action that is based on a heartfelt desire to protect the environment for future generations.

The student activists could argue that, even if their action is against school policy, it is a sound moral imperative, and the price of doing nothing would consign their generation to a diminished life.

Hence, it becomes important to discuss the rights of high school students to oppose the government’s current climate change policies.

Specifically, the youth activists agitated against the proposed extension of a coal mine in Queensland. They argued that such extension could cause injury, or even death, arising from carbon dioxide emissions and subsequent global warming.

One could add that the students’ actions had been influenced by the global climate change religion, spearheaded by an angry-looking Swedish student, Greta Thunberg.

Of course, this opinion piece does not lend itself to a considered analysis of the appropriateness of allowing an extension of the coal mine, except to say that such a decision must always involve a review of employment opportunities, the local economy, and well-being of the population, in addition to the level of expected pollution that the extension would generate.

An assessment of the students’ action could learn from an iconic decision of the American Supreme Court, Tinker v Des Moines Independent Community School District, decided in 1969.

It involved the wearing of black armbands by school students in breach of an established school policy to denounce the American involvement in the Vietnam war.

The Supreme Court held that the student’s right to wear a black armband constitutes an example of a special kind of protected speech—“symbolic speech”—even though the students’ action violated established school policy.

In instances of “symbolic speech,” the court said that “freedom of expression would not truly exist if the right could be exercised only in an area that a benevolent government has provided as a safe haven for crackpots.”

“The Constitution says that Congress (and the states) may not abridge the right to free speech. This provision means what it says. We properly read it to permit reasonable regulation of speech-connected activities in carefully restricted circumstances. But we do not confine the permissible exercise of First Amendment rights to a telephone booth or the four corners of a pamphlet, or to supervised and ordained discussion in a school classroom,” the court said.

Similarly, in the earlier case of Musser v Utah, the Supreme Court stated that the “position, that the state may prevent any conduct which induces people to violate the law, or any advocacy of unlawful activity, cannot be squared with the First Amendment.”

Nevertheless, one could legitimately ask the question of whether it would be better for youth activists to spend their energy and commendable enthusiasm on the recuperation of the rights lost during the COVID-19 pandemic, instead of focusing single-mindedly on climate change and global warming.

The question acknowledges that, at present, a person’s civil rights are under tremendous stress and routinely violated by policymakers, trendsetters, and autocratic politicians, who typically follow the recommendations of the bureaucratic health brigade.

The student activists live in an era where civil rights are violated in the name of health. During the last two years, these rights have been swept away by government-sponsored policies to protect the health of Australians, disregarding their civil rights.

Certainly, although climate change is an important societal issue, Joyce’s comments implied that the high school student activists, rather than being concerned with climate change, should worry about matters of life and death and about the liberal and Christian origins of Australia and our civil rights which are embedded in the legal system.

To conclude: while the students’ protests are legal as an expression of “symbolic speech”—and certainly not an exercise in futility—based on legitimate moral concerns, they could nevertheless be regarded as narcissistic emanations of young people who should ideally concentrate on their studies before becoming climate change activists—because there is much to learn and unlearn.

Read rest at The Epoch Times

  • Truth
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Gettr
  • Threads
  • gab-logo Gab
  • Mastodon
  • Buffer
  • Telegram
  • Email
  • Copy Link
  • Share Using More Networks…

Popular Posts

Electric Vehicles (EVs)

The ‘Green’ Scam Of The Century: How ‘Renewables’ Increase Fossil Fuel Demands

Oct 23, 2024
News and Opinion

Antarctica Is Colder, Icier Today Than At Any Time In 5,000 Years

Apr 15, 2024
Energy

30-Plus Signs That The Climate Scam Is Collapsing

Apr 09, 2025

Comments 3

  1. Graham McDonald says:
    4 years ago

    Amendment 1
    – Freedom of Religion, Speech, and the Press
    Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.

    So Congress, and the several States via the 14th Amendment, may not “… abridge the freedom of speech …”

    It says nothing about local rules being imposed, even though they may be at a local government conducted school, or via a non-government entity.

    Facebook, Twitter, YouTube anyone?

  2. Spurwing Plover says:
    4 years ago

    Watch as they march right into Socialism and then they lose everything including their Basic Human Rights all over Fake Crisis

  3. Steve Bunten says:
    4 years ago

    Those eight HS students wouldn’t know what a tort is if it hit them along side the head. There are adults involved who push this whole idea of using the courts to create a new tort out of thin air.

Stay Connected On Social Media

gab-logo

Donate Today

Beating back the alarmist narrative takes time and money. Please donate today to help!

Recent Posts

  • France Aude wildfireWhen Climate Science Gets Ignored, Weather Porn Drives Headlines And Policy
    Oct 21, 2025
    Climate warnings rely on debunked, overstated science, so when new data disproves the scare, media and officials stay largely silent. […]
  • Markey Warren, the OGs of the Green New ScamDems Dial Back Climate Alarm, Pivot To Soaring Electricity Bills They Caused
    Oct 21, 2025
    Democrats downplay climate policy as they shift to rising electricity costs that their green policies and unsustainable subsidies caused. […]
  • climate griftThe Climate Grift Unravels: Sec. Wright Saves Billions By Canceling Wasteful Projects
    Oct 21, 2025
    Secretary Wright has exposed Biden-era climate waste, clawing back billions lost to corruption and green boondoggles. […]
  • Unloading cargo shipRough Seas Ahead: The Coming Fight Over Net Zero Shipping
    Oct 20, 2025
    Net-zero shipping can’t work — but that won’t stop UN bureaucrats from trying to institute a carbon tax again and profiting off its failure. […]
  • Eagle sits on power pole near wind farmSecretary Burgum Orders Crackdown On Wind Turbines Killing Bald And Golden Eagles
    Oct 20, 2025
    Secretary Burgum orders action against wind turbines killing Bald and Golden Eagles, targeting years of government neglect. […]
  • day after tomorrowNew Study Shows AMOC Stable, Contradicting Alarmist Narrative
    Oct 20, 2025
    New research finds the AMOC is stable, challenging claims that the Atlantic current is weakening and triggering extreme cooling. […]
  • Children's Trust RallyGen Z Used To Whip Up Global Climate Lawsuits; Critics Call It Brainwashing
    Oct 20, 2025
    Critics warn left-wing activists are using Gen Z to drum up more global climate lawsuits using fear, brainwashing, and alarmist training materials. […]
  • KamalaKamala Blames ‘Climate Anxiety’ For Young Americans Avoiding Parenthood
    Oct 20, 2025
    Harris says young Americans fear having kids due to ‘climate anxiety,’ echoing alarmist messaging promoted for years by her party and media allies. […]
  • Antarctic Peninsula PenguinsState Of The Climate 2024: ‘No Runaway Warming, No Climate Crisis’
    Oct 17, 2025
    Observational data shows global temperatures, sea levels, and other climate trends remain within normal ranges, with no sign of an emergency. […]
  • cargo shipU.S. Blocks Global Shipping Carbon Tax, Delays IMO Vote One Year
    Oct 17, 2025
    Trump administration successfully blocked a global shipping carbon tax, forcing a one-year delay on the IMO’s vote. […]

Get Instant Email Notifications

Subscribe to receive a digest of daily stories, or get emailed once they're published. Check your Junk/Spam folder for a verification email.

Submit a tip

Please enter your email, so we know you're human.

Books You May Like

exposing great lie

Have a suggestion? Let us know! We swap out books based on your input. We participate in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. See here.

  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

© Portions copyright Climate Change Dispatch

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Who We Are
  • Facts Vs. Fearmongering
    • Real science vs Junk Science
      • 1100-plus Peer-Reviewed Studies
      • 97% – Myth of the Climate Change Consensus
      • Michael Crichton: Aliens Cause Global Warming
      • Climate change and its causes
      • Climate Science Primer
      • CO2 is not pollution
      • Deceptive Surface Temperature Records
      • Editorial: Great Global Warming Hoax
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 1
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 2
      • Rules for Climate Radicals: Part 3
      • Why CO2 Is A Minor Player In Global Climate
      • Why Politicized Science Is So Dangerous
    • Facts Not Fear
      • A Simple Question For Climate Alarmists
      • Climate Change – The Facts
      • Climate Change Fears Are Empirically Baseless
      • Global Warming 101
      • Global Warming Q&A
      • Understanding The Medieval Warm Period
      • Ocean Cycles and Climate
      • Overview of Plate Climatology Theory
      • Precautionary Principle
      • Should We Celebrate Carbon Dioxide?
      • The Skeptics Handbook
      • Weather Versus Climate
      • Why I’m a GW skeptic
      • Winning the climate debate with facts
      • Why Aliens Cause Global Warming
    • Greenhouse FAQs
      • CO2, Plants, & Industry
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • How much have temps changed?
      • Is global warming real?
      • Measuring temperature
      • Swimming in CO2?
      • Scientists urge caution?
      • Today’s warming trend
      • Variations in temperature
    • Gore’s Greatest Goofs
      • Deconstructing the Truth
      • Fact-Checking Al Gore’s Latest Predictions
      • How Gore Created The Global Warming Hoax
    • Inside Real Climate
      • Closer look at the 97% Consensus
      • GW’s Amazing Story
      • IPCC gets failing grade
      • Real Climate Exposed!
      • Truth about Real Climate
      • We’ve Been Conned
      • What is there a 97% consensus about?
    • Behind the IPCC
      • 1,000 Scientists Dissent
      • Climategate: Caught Green-Handed!
      • Climategate Inquiries
      • Climategate Inquiries 2
      • NIPCC Report Now Available
      • Understanding the Climategate Inquiries
  • Submissions
  • Contact Us

© 2025 Climate Change Dispatch

 
Share via
  • Facebook
  • Like
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • Tumblr
  • VKontakte
  • Print
  • Email
  • Reddit
  • Buffer
  • Love This
  • Weibo
  • Pocket
  • Xing
  • Odnoklassniki
  • WhatsApp
  • Meneame
  • Blogger
  • Amazon
  • Yahoo Mail
  • Gmail
  • AOL
  • Newsvine
  • HackerNews
  • Evernote
  • MySpace
  • Mail.ru
  • Viadeo
  • Line
  • Flipboard
  • Comments
  • SMS
  • Viber
  • Telegram
  • Subscribe
  • Facebook Messenger
  • Kakao
  • LiveJournal
  • Yammer
  • Edgar
  • Fintel
  • Mix
  • Instapaper
  • Copy Link
  • Truth
  • gab-logo Gab
  • Gettr
  • Baidu
  • Mastodon
  • Threads
  • Bluesky
Share via
  • Digg
  • Tumblr
  • VKontakte
  • Print
  • Email
  • Reddit
  • Buffer
  • Love This
  • Weibo
  • Pocket
  • Xing
  • Odnoklassniki
  • WhatsApp
  • Meneame
  • Blogger
  • Amazon
  • Yahoo Mail
  • Gmail
  • AOL
  • Newsvine
  • HackerNews
  • Evernote
  • MySpace
  • Mail.ru
  • Viadeo
  • Line
  • Flipboard
  • Comments
  • SMS
  • Viber
  • Telegram
  • Subscribe
  • Facebook Messenger
  • Kakao
  • LiveJournal
  • Yammer
  • Edgar
  • Fintel
  • Mix
  • Instapaper
  • Copy Link
  • Truth
  • gab-logo Gab
  • Gettr
  • Baidu
  • Mastodon
  • Threads
  • Bluesky