Sen. Whitehouse Knows Nothing About Elementary Climate Science

Sheldon WhitehouseJust a quick take on this morning’s U.S. Senate Environment and Public Works Committee hearing, ‘Examining the Role of Environmental Policies on Access to Energy and Economic Opportunity.’  During the hearing, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) demonstrated why the global warming debate so often gets sidetracked by nonsensical and incorrect assertions.

The senator made two statements that were both factually incorrect, demonstrating his obvious lack of understanding of even the most basic climate science.

[1]  The senator said that “we are in unprecedented territory” when it comes to carbon dioxide content in the atmosphere.  Sen. Whitehouse noted that atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) levels have ranged from 170 parts per million (ppm) to 300 ppm over the past 800,000 years, and the current level of 400 ppm is thus dangerous and exceptional.  In fact, atmospheric CO2 concentrations have ranged widely throughout the earth’s geologic history, and have typically existed at levels far higher than today. 

CO2 levels currently register at 0.04% of the atmosphere, an almost non-existent concentration that means near-starvation for plant life.  In fact, the past 800,000 years have seen the earth struggling to survive the repeated glacial periods of an ice age, with atmospheric CO2 gradually dropping to some of the lowest levels in the planet’s history.

[2]  The senator stated that carbon dioxide and temperature have moved in parallel for much of geologic history, and thus rising CO2 will mean higher temperatures.  This is one of the most mischaracterized and misunderstood mechanisms of climate science.  Carbon dioxide’s solubility in water is governed by temperature.  When the climate cools, the oceans draw in more CO2, thus lowering atmospheric CO2 content.  When the climate warms, as seen at the start of the most recent interglacial period (roughly 18,000 years ago) for example, the oceans gradually expel CO2.  (This is the reason why a bottle of soda kept in hot sunlight will leak or burst— because the warmer soda is no longer able to hold all of the dissolved CO2.)  Thus, it is changes in temperature that govern subsequent changes in atmospheric CO2 concentration, not the other way around (as the senator simply assumes.)

These two assertions by Sen. Whitehouse misrepresent the most basic facts of paleoclimate science.  And yet, blithely unaware of this, the senator chooses to make pronouncements, and to advocate policies, that could mean great pain for millions of Americans.

What’s needed is for America’s elected officials to educate themselves on some of the basic facts regarding climate before making sweeping, errant pronouncements.

Trackback from your site.

Leave a comment (newest first):

Comments (5)

  • Avatar

    Get Real

    |

    Is it safe to assume then that 97% of politicians are scientifically illiterate?

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Amber

    |

    “Misrepresent the most basic facts” seems to be a pattern when the scientifically illiterate are talking nonsense to others of the same background .
    Nice to have his understanding of basic science revealed though . You keep talkin there Mr . Whitehouse . Can we expect a drowning Polar bear story or perhaps a forecast of when we can expect an ice free Arctic .
    Everyone one else seems to make them just a little to close to be proven wrong so there is a little hint .

    Reply

  • Avatar

    John Wilder

    |

    The author of the article is wrong on two important counts. First of all the atmospheric level of CO2 is not .o4%. 400 PPM is a fractional equivalent of 40/100,000ths of 1%. So the correct answer is
    .000004% of the atmosphere.

    Secondly CO2 does not dissolve in liquid. It is a gas and therefore can’t dissolve. It can only be forced into suspension in a closed container. Once the container is opened it evacuates the container in a short period of time

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Me

    |

    1%= 10,000 ppm or mgkg or mgl so do your math again John.

    Reply

  • Avatar

    Stevencap

    |

    John Wilder, thanks for your comment. But CO2 is indeed water soluble. And 400 parts per million is the same as 0.04%.

    Reply

Leave a comment

Loading Disqus Comments ...

No Trackbacks.