Professor Michael Mann recently filed a defamation suit against National Review Online et al (download legal complaint here and here) based on articles written by various authors that called into question his famous hockey stick graph of global warming temperatures.
In the lawsuit, Mann makes the claim that he has been “awarded the Nobel Peace Prize” in the complaint itself (page 2, paragraph 2). He premises much of his argument/suit that by winning such a prestigious prize, he has the right to sue the aforementioned authors for defamation of character.
I contacted The Norwegian Nobel Institute to find out if Mann was indeed a Nobel Laureate, winner, etc… My questions were:
- Was Prof Michael Mann ‘awarded’ a Nobel Prize of any sort at any time? Is he a Nobel Laureate as implied elsewhere in his legal brief?
Did he receive a certificate “for contributing to” the IPCC Nobel Peace Prize? Is the photo of the certificate authentic? [see photo]
Is there a difference between stating you “were awarded” the Nobel Peace Prize as indicated by Mann in his legal brief and “contributing to” as shown in the attached photo of the certificate?
Geir Lundestad, Director, Professor, of The Norwegian Nobel Institute emailed me back with the following:
1) Michael Mann has never been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.
2) He did not receive any personal certificate. He has taken the diploma awarded in 2007 to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (and to Al Gore) and made his own text underneath this authentic-looking diploma.
3) The text underneath the diploma is entirely his own. We issued only the diploma to the IPCC as such. No individuals on the IPCC side received anything in 2007.
Lundestad goes on to say that, “Unfortunately we often experience that members of organizations that have indeed been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize issue various forms of personal diplomas to indicate that they personally have received the Nobel Peace Prize. They have not.”
So it would appear that not only did Mann not get awarded the Nobel Peace Prize but that the “text underneath the diploma is entirely his own.” This calls into further questions of what else may not be factual in the lawsuit over the highly publicized hockey-stick graph and defamation suit.
Michael Mann even twitted, “IPCC certificate acknowledging me “contributing to award of the Nobel Peace Prize”. Do they want my birth certif too?” It would appear the answer is yes.
Update from Climate Depot: The IPCC issued the certificates with the text on them to IPCC participants, including Mann. Mann did not add the text himself. Here is a photo of a UN IPCC issued certificate (LINK)
Archived here from Examiner.com